In my lifetime, the conservative Anabaptist community has faced tremendous pressure from increasingly sophisticated progressive theologies. I have seen many mainline Mennonite conferences embrace positions that are incompatible with Scripture. This has caused faithful believers to seek solid ground. Many have turned to historical scholarship, early church fathers, and contemporary scholars, seeking frameworks to defend the true biblical faith against what is seen as liberal drift. As biblical authority is dismissed, conservatives naturally look for credible voices who take Scripture seriously. As liberal theology erodes foundational doctrines, faithful believers want robust teaching that honors God’s Word while engaging these intellectual challenges.
In seeking to resist the advance of progressive theology, many conservative Anabaptists have unknowingly adopted a scholarly framework that discredits the very scriptural authority they seek to defend. Books which promote this framework are appearing on the recommended reading lists of conservative organizations. This teaching is being circulated in faithful communities, and Bible studies use study materials which include it. Many contain a subtle but powerful reinterpretation of the gospel that changes how justification, atonement, and salvation itself are understood.
This framework goes by various names in scholarly circles. It is called the New Perspective on Paul (NPP), covenantal nomism, or gospel allegiance. Most conservative Anabaptists have never heard these terms, but the ideas are spreading through their communities, often framed as a return to early Christianity or an understanding of Paul’s original context.
Conservative Anabaptists correctly recognize that faith must produce obedience and that a grace that does not produce fruit is unbiblical. But they do not recognize that the scholarly framework they are adopting to articulate these truths can distort the gospel. Sorting through these competing frameworks requires the discipline of repeatedly returning to Scripture itself, letting God’s Word speak plainly without the mediation of a scholarly reconstruction. In this three-part series, I will examine this hidden framework: how it works, why it appeals to conservative Anabaptists, and why it must be recognized. This is not an argument against obedience, church discipline, historic Christianity, or the simple wisdom of learning from the past. It is an argument about the limits of historical reconstruction as a theological authority, especially when it is used within a tradition born from resistance to interpretation that requires worldly authority.
Understanding the Framework: Getting In Versus Staying In
In 1977, E. P. Sanders argued that first-century Judaism wasn’t about legalistic works-righteousness.1 He presented the Jews as understanding themselves as already God’s covenant people by gracious election. The law, the Torah, maintained their status as covenant people. Sanders called this covenantal nomism. Election by God’s grace established the relationship, and obedience to Torah maintained it. Sanders articulated this pattern in eight points describing how ancient Judaism understood salvation.
- God chose Israel by grace, not merit.
- God gave the law to Israel as a gift and guide.
- The law implies God’s promise to maintain Israel’s election.
- The law requires obedience to maintain one’s standing within the elect community.
- God rewards obedience and punishes transgression.
- When covenant members sin, the law provides for restoration through a means of atonement.
- Atonement results in the maintenance or reestablishing of the covenant relationship when it is broken by disobedience.
- All who maintain the covenant by obedience, atonement, and God’s continuing mercy belong to those who will be rewarded with final salvation.
In this structure, Sanders is proposing that Judaism wasn’t legalistic. That means when Paul criticizes works of the law in his letters, he can’t be arguing against Jewish attempts to earn a covenant relationship through works. He must be arguing something else entirely. Scholars like James D. G. Dunn and N. T. Wright took Sanders’ work and applied it to reading Paul.2 They argued that Paul’s critique of works of the law was not about legalism or works-righteousness at all. Instead, Paul was addressing Jewish exclusivism, the insistence that Gentiles must adopt Jewish boundary markers such as circumcision, food laws, and Sabbath observance to be in the covenant. According to this view, Paul wasn’t saying you can’t earn salvation by works. He was saying Gentiles don’t need to become Jewish to be included in God’s covenant people. Not every scholar accepted this move. A. Andrew Das argues that Paul reasons about the law from Christ, not from a reconstruction of Second Temple Judaism. In his words, Paul’s demand for full obedience to the law is “not necessarily a commentary on Second Temple Judaism, but a consequence of his Christological emphases.”3
When this was applied to Christianity, it said that God saves you by grace through faith in Christ. That’s getting into the covenant community. But once you’re in, staying in requires the same faithful obedience shown in the list above. Yes, there’s forgiveness when you sin, but your standing is maintained by your ongoing allegiance to Jesus as King. In this framework, salvation is not primarily about being declared righteous before God, but about getting included in God’s covenant community through loyal obedience. Key biblical words are redefined. The Greek word pistis, traditionally translated as “faith” or “trust,” gets redefined as “allegiance” or “loyalty.”4 When pistis becomes allegiance, salvation shifts from trusting Christ’s finished work to pledging loyalty demonstrated through obedient living.
To remain consistent with these statements, the framework requires reinterpreting Christ’s death itself. Salvation becomes primarily about covenant inclusion rather than justification, and the cross’s meaning shifts. Christ’s crucifixion becomes primarily a demonstration of covenant faithfulness, an example of love, or victory over evil powers. You may still hear the phrase “Christ died for our sins,” but that phrase has been fundamentally redefined. “For our sins” no longer means bearing the punishment our sins deserved, but rather establishing the covenant that includes us, or showing us the path of faithful obedience. The blood of Christ becomes less about propitiation and more about demonstrating covenant love or defeating spiritual enemies. This framework requires a historical reconstruction of the purpose of the law to control scriptural interpretation. NPP scholars insist that understanding Paul requires first reconstructing ancient Judaism through scholarly research, making Scripture’s meaning dependent on the expert’s knowledge. This elevates historical scholarship to interpretive authority over Scripture’s plain reading, and the Bible’s meaning becomes inaccessible to ordinary believers without this scholarly mediation.
Why This Appeals to Conservative Anabaptists
This has powerful appeal for faithful Anabaptist believers, and understanding why helps us recognize how this teaching spreads even among those committed to Scripture. Below are four factors that drive its adoption.
First, the framework appears to validate the Anabaptist emphasis on obedience. We have always insisted that faith produces obedient living. We have rightly rejected the idea that someone can claim to have saving faith while showing no evidence of transformation. When scholars present a framework where staying in the covenant requires a demonstration of obedience, it seems to provide intellectual support and scholarly validation for what conservative Anabaptists have always believed. It appears to solve the tension between Paul’s teaching that we are saved by grace through faith apart from works and James’s teaching that faith without works is dead.
Second, the framework seems to defend against cheap grace. Conservative Anabaptists have watched evangelical churches fill with people who have made public decisions for Christ but show no evidence of regeneration. When this framework insists that allegiance must be demonstrated, and that covenant membership involves more than a momentary decision, it sounds like the needed corrective.
Third, the framework emphasizes community over individualism in ways that resonate deeply with Anabaptist ecclesiology. When salvation is defined primarily as inclusion in God’s covenant people rather than an individual legal standing before God, this framework seems to align perfectly with the convictions Anabaptists hold about the church. When scholars present justification as fundamentally about covenant membership rather than God’s declaration of righteousness, it sounds like communal Christianity has been recovered, and it seems an antidote to American evangelical hyper-individualism.
Fourth, the framework comes with impressive scholarly credentials. When conservative Anabaptists face intellectual arguments from progressive theologians, this framework offers something powerfully attractive: a sophisticated biblical scholarship that is both academically credible and theologically sound. Respected scholars from prestigious institutions write learned books claiming to have discovered through historical research what the gospel really meant in its original context.
The Biblical Problems: What Gets Lost
With the adoption of this framework, Christ’s death becomes less central to the individual, shifted from bearing the chastisement for our peace to demonstrating covenant faithfulness. When Scripture declares, “He was wounded for our transgressions, He was bruised for our iniquities; the chastisement for our peace was upon Him” (Isaiah 53:5), it is not speaking about covenant demonstration. Second, assurance becomes uncertain. If staying saved depends on maintained obedience, how faithful is faithful enough? We can point to forgiveness, but the structure remains. Salvation partly depends on my performance. This lacks safeguards against categories of acceptable sin. The church confronted this error in the fifth century when Pelagius taught that humans could achieve righteousness through moral effort. Whatever the many personal conflicts in that controversy, the theological judgment was sound. Humans are “dead in trespasses and sins” (Ephesians 2:1), unable to save themselves. Grace must be God’s work from the beginning to the end, or it ceases to be grace.
Without the safeguard that “He who has begun a good work in you will complete it” (Philippians 1:6), apostasy cannot be biblically explained in this framework. Generally, when someone professes faith but produces no works, this isn’t evidence that grace has failed but reveals a state of apostasy. In apostasy, many fail to recognize they are actively rejecting grace. It is not grace rejecting them. Rather, apostasy is a determination to please the flesh without regard to the power of a transformed life. Grace can intervene in a life, but it does not automatically override the desires that one tends and feeds. When Paul commands us to put those desires to death, this is not a task anyone can accomplish on their own. It requires the very grace being rejected. “They went out from us, but they were not of us; for if they had been of us, they would have continued with us” (1 John 2:19). The third casualty, among the most dangerous for Anabaptist communities, is the collapse of the “already but not yet” tension, a collapse that I will develop in the next article.
In Part Two, we will examine how this framework collapses the biblical tension between “already” and “not yet,” transforms the church’s mission from witness to activism, and undermines the historic Anabaptist two-kingdom theology that has sustained faithful communities for nearly 500 years.
Footnotes
- E. P. Sanders, Paul and Palestinian Judaism: A Comparison of Patterns of Religion (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1977), 75, 422. ↩︎
- James D. G. Dunn, The New Perspective on Paul, rev. ed. (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2008); N. T. Wright, What Saint Paul Really Said (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1997). ↩︎
- A. Andrew Das, “The Traditional Protestant Perspective on Paul,” in Perspectives on Paul: Five Views, ed. Scot McKnight and B. J. Oropeza (Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2020), 94. Das develops his wider critique of covenantal nomism as a category for Paul in Paul and the Jews (Peabody, MA: Hendrickson, 2003). His work stands in the background of this series more than the citations show. ↩︎
- Matthew W. Bates, Salvation by Allegiance Alone: Rethinking Faith, Works, and the Gospel of Jesus the King (Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2017). ↩︎


